There’s no doubt that sea moss has incredible benefits. That’s why it’s been so valued by different cultures across the centuries. Now, with the world at our fingertips, the question people are asking: is Irish or Jamaican sea moss better?
Let’s find out.
What Are the Different Types of Sea Moss Available Today?
Sea moss is actually a name that covers different species. While there are over a hundred found in nature, these are the top 5 that have been adopted by the wellness, food, and beauty industries:
-
Irish sea moss (Chondrus crispus): Found in the cold Atlantic waters near Ireland and Northern Europe, Irish sea moss is darker in colour with vivid reds or purples. It’s been used in food and remedies for generations.
-
Jamaican sea moss (Gracilaria species): Growing in the warm Caribbean seas, this moss can be golden, purple, or green. It has a soft texture and a mild taste. Purple Jamaican sea moss, in particular, is especially high in antioxidants.
-
St. Lucian sea moss: Another Caribbean variety, this sea moss is harvested around St. Lucia. It has a similar profile to Jamaican sea moss and tends to be sold under its island name to highlight its origin.
-
Eucheuma sea moss: Found in tropical regions like East Africa and the Philippines, this algae is used to extract carrageenan for the food industry.
-
Pool-grown sea moss: Farmed in artificial saltwater pools, this affordable option usually has fewer minerals and a different texture compared to wild, ocean-grown moss. It can also be prone to chemicals and additives.
While all of these mosses have their own benefits, the most popular ones are Irish sea moss and Jamaican sea moss. They’re both simple to add to your daily wellness routine and have their own benefits.
Here’s a closer look at these in-demand supplements.
Jamaican Sea Moss vs Irish Sea Moss: Nutritional Profile Breakdown
Both Irish and Jamaican sea moss are powerful, nutritious supplements that are rich in minerals like iodine, calcium, and magnesium.
However, they come from very different environments. The cold Irish seas and the warm Caribbean waters shape their texture, flavour, and overall nutritional balance.
Both Jamaican sea moss and Irish sea moss are packed with minerals like iodine, calcium, iron, and magnesium. These are all essential for energy, thyroid health, and strong bones.
The Unique Benefits of Jamaican Sea Moss You Should Know
While both Irish and Jamaican sea moss have loads of health benefits, Jamaican purple sea moss in particular is supercharged with antioxidant power. These antioxidants can:
-
Support skin hydration and natural glow
-
Protect cells from oxidative stress
-
Promote healthy ageing and recovery
When adding a new supplement to your wellness routine, consistency is crucial. You need to take sea moss gel every day to build up the minerals and get the most out of it.
Thanks to the tropical climate, Jamaican sea moss grows year-round, making it fresh and widely available. This gives you a reliable quality with every batch.
Taste, Texture, and Colour: How Jamaican and Irish Sea Moss Compare
While the nutrient profile of sea moss is extremely important, taste and texture play a huge role in sustainable habits. The reality is, if it's not easy to add to a daily routine, the chances of longer-term use are low. And, without long-term use, the benefits go right out the window.
Here’s a look at how Jamaican and Irish sea moss compare:
Taste & Texture
Jamaican sea moss gel has a lovely, mild ocean flavour that makes it easy to split into a smoothie or porridge. Our organic sea moss gel is so smooth that you can even mix it into your afternoon tea.
Irish sea moss, on the other hand, has a much stronger oceanic flavour. While it’s still a popular ingredient in food, if it’s not rinsed and prepared well, the sea will be the dominant flavour. The carrageenan content acts as a thickener and stabiliser, so you can use it in pudding, ice cream, and even cosmetic recipes.
Color Profile
You can tell the difference between the two sea mosses just based on colour. Irish sea moss is in the pale yellow to deep red colour spectrum. Depending on the time of year, Jamaican sea moss can be golden or purple.
What are the side effects of Jamaican sea moss?
Jamaican sea moss is safe for most people to enjoy. Always follow the recommended amount, which is typically 1-2 tablespoons. If you take too much or are particularly sensitive, you may experience side effects.
Some potential issues are:
-
Excess iodine intake – too much may affect thyroid function.
-
Digestive changes – bloating, gas, or an upset stomach when first starting. Extreme cases can lead to ulcers.
-
Allergic reactions – those sensitive to seaweed or with shellfish allergies should take care.
-
Medication interactions – high mineral content may interfere with some treatments.
Irish sea moss, in particular, can have blood-thinning properties. So, like any supplement, it's always best to consult with a healthcare professional.
A Sea Moss Price Comparison
As the saying goes, you get what you pay for. Typically, Irish moss is cheaper. It’s widely used in the food industry, so it’s regularly available. Wild Irish moss can be a bit more expensive than farm-grown. The same goes for farm Jamaican sea moss. It’s cheaper to make sea moss when manufacturers use chemicals and artificial reefs, like rope, to grow their sea moss.
Wildcrafted Jamaican sea moss has a premium price tag. Because it’s hand-harvested and sundried, it takes more labour to produce. There’s also a more limited supply, but it's as pure as it can be outside of nature.
Sea Moss Colour
Another price factor is colour. Purple and green varieties tend to cost more than gold sea moss. These colours are rarer and have some extra properties. While all sea moss is rich in minerals, purple Jamaican sea moss tends to be higher in antioxidants, whereas green sea moss is more detoxifying.
Gold sea moss is naturally bleached by the sun and saltwater, which is why it's so common. Purple sea moss achieves its stunning pigment after it's been dried in the shade. This process preserves its original pigment and high antioxidant concentration.
Green sea moss is the rarest simple because there’s just less of it in nature. It’s also much harder to preserve its colour when drying.
Sea Moss Price Cheatsheet
The price of sea moss varies greatly, depending on where it’s from, how it's processed, and its colour. Specific pricing will vary by supplier, but here’s a good guide to use when considering which sea moss is best for you:
Which Sea Moss Should You Choose Based on Your Needs?
The best sea moss for you depends on what you’re looking for. Each type has its own strengths, so it helps to match your choice to your goals. Irish sea moss is a great budget-friendly option, while Jamaican sea moss has a smoother texture and higher antioxidants.
When it comes to top-tier wellness, our wild Jamaican sea moss is packed with its natural nutrients, delivering 92 essential minerals in a ready-to-use gel.
Explore Jamaican Sea Moss
